Marcus Claudius Marcellus (c. 270–208 BC) was the most celebrated Roman field general of the Second Punic War after Quintus Fabius Maximus. He had been one of the two consuls of 222 BC and had personally killed the Gallic king Viridomarus in single combat at the Battle of Clastidium that year — substantively winning the spolia opima, the rare Roman military honour awarded only to a general who killed an enemy commander in single combat (only three Romans in the entire Republican period earned it). He held five consulships in total, an exceptional career even by the standards of the Roman senatorial elite.
He is remembered in classical literature for two specific qualities that were unusual in a Roman field commander: he was a substantial cultural philhellene, and he wept publicly over Syracuse.
The siege
The Sicilian city of Syracuse had been a substantial Roman ally through the long reign of King Hiero II (270–215 BC), the substantial mathematical patron who had commissioned Archimedes’s most famous works — including the water-displacement crown analysis from Vitruvius’s Eureka story. Hiero died in 215 BC; his teenage successor Hieronymus reversed the city’s foreign policy and allied with Carthage; the Roman Senate dispatched Marcellus to recover the city in 213 BC.
The Roman siege took two years. The reason was Archimedes. The mathematician — then approximately 75 — had designed a range of defensive military machines for the city: claw-like grapples that lifted Roman ships out of the water and dropped them; mechanical artillery that could be aimed accurately at moving targets; reportedly (though contested) a system of mirrors that focused sunlight to ignite ship sails. Marcellus made multiple assaults on the city walls and was repulsed by Archimedes’s mechanical artillery each time. He eventually gave up direct assault and reduced the city through blockade.
The breakthrough came in autumn 212 BC at a religious festival; Marcellus identified a under-watched section of the city walls, sent a small assault force over them at night, and took the city through the resulting confusion.
What happened to Archimedes
Marcellus had given specific written orders to his subordinate officers that Archimedes was to be taken alive and brought to him unharmed. The Roman cultural respect for Greek intellectual achievement was genuine in Marcellus’s case; he understood that Archimedes was a international intellectual treasure whose loss would be a cultural disaster.
The orders failed. Plutarch’s Life of Marcellus preserves three substantively different versions of how Archimedes died, all attributed to Roman traditions that had reached Plutarch through Polybius and earlier sources:
-
Archimedes was substantively absorbed in a geometric diagram drawn in the sand when a Roman soldier demanded he come along to Marcellus; Archimedes refused to leave until he had finished the proof; the soldier ran him through.
-
Archimedes was substantively carrying mathematical instruments (a sundial, a astronomical sphere) when an enterprising soldier mistook them for valuables and killed him to take them.
-
Archimedes was substantively going voluntarily to Marcellus, carrying mathematical instruments, when a different soldier mistook him for an armed combatant and killed him.
The three versions agree on the outcome: Marcellus arrived at Archimedes’s house to find the mathematician dead. He substantively had the responsible soldier identified and had him executed. He substantively had Archimedes’s body recovered and arranged for the state funeral that the mathematician had not been able to anticipate.
The tomb
The Archimedean tomb that Marcellus arranged at Syracuse was marked with a geometric carving: a sphere inscribed in a cylinder, with the associated proof showing that the volume of the sphere is two-thirds the volume of the circumscribed cylinder — the result that Archimedes had himself considered his most mathematical accomplishment.
The tomb fell into neglect through the following centuries. The Roman politician Cicero, serving as the Roman quaestor of Sicily in 75 BC, rediscovered the overgrown tomb in a Syracusan cemetery and had it restored. The tomb survives in the 21st-century Syracuse archaeological landscape only through the Cicero account; the physical tomb itself has not been substantively definitively identified by modern excavation.
The Roman cultural inheritance
Marcellus returned to Rome in 211 BC with the captured Syracusan art collection — the first transfer of Greek high art into Roman elite possession on significant scale. The Roman subsequent substantive cultural absorption of Hellenistic art dates from the Marcellan 211 BC Syracuse transfer.
He substantively died in battle in 208 BC, ambushed by Hannibal’s cavalry in southern Italy. His career had absorbed substantive Greek cultural substantive elements that the substantive Roman substantive senatorial tradition had substantively previously substantively largely substantively excluded.